Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Petition Expedition – Cancer in Laundry Detergent?

On Facebook and other social media sites, online petitions quickly gather steam. Users see others’ posts, rally to the cause, and spread word to their friends and families using “Likes” and “+1s.” However, this rush to join also belies a lack of judgment; as the petition becomes easier to circulate and sign, critical reading of its content diminishes.

Source: P&G
Take the example of Tide Free & Gentle, a popular laundry detergent advertised as free from dyes and perfumes.  Political site has recently posted a petition titled “Tide: Get Cancer-Causing Chemicals Out of Laundry Detergent.” This petition focuses on one specific compound purportedly isolated from detergent: 1,4-dioxane. As of March 6, it had amassed >68,000 signatures, just under 1 month after going live (I caught it making the rounds on both Facebook and Twitter).

The petition references data from a recent report, published online last November by Women’s Voices for the Earth, an environmental awareness organization based out of Montana. Dubbed Dirty Secrets: What’s Hiding in Your Cleaning Products?, the report aims to expose “hidden toxic chemicals” in household products, cleaners, and air fresheners (see here for P&G’s published Tide F&G ingredient list).

(Disclaimer: I am a chemist by profession, and I’m not advocating corporate secrecy or consumer harm. I’m just trying to critically analyze the data before making decisions.)

I think this post might function better as a Q&A.

 Q1 – What is dioxane, anyway? Can it harm me?

1,4-Dioxane is a cyclic diether (2 oxygens, 4 carbons, 6-membered ring). Chemists use it to dissolve compounds for reactions. It possesses specific properties (chelation, high-boiling, water solubility) that make it attractive for certain reactions over other solvents. According to its MSDS, dioxane can irritate the skin eyes, and nasal passages, but only by acute (large amount in small timeframe) dose.

Q2 – Does it cause cancer?

Dioxane lists as a 2B – Possible Human Carcinogen.  Note the exact wording there. Two other levels exist for compounds known to cause human cancers, 2A (Probable) and 1 (Known Carcinogen). If you enter “dioxane” into TOXNET and browse the carcinogenicity data, you’ll find studies on rats where ~1.0% dioxane in drinking water caused liver tumors in many cases, also squamous cell carcinomas, and a single report of mammary gland tumors over two years’ exposure (Dirty Secrets mentions only breast cancer, and calls dioxane a “known cancer-causing substance”).

Q3 – Well, what did the report actually find?

Good question. Page 10 of the report lists the data for Tide Free & Gentle, which indicates 89.00 ppm dioxane, and 0.8 ppm limonene, a fragrance isolated from citrus peels. Now, ppm? Parts per million, meaning that 89 milligrams are found in each liter of detergent. Put another way, if you round up to 100 ppm, it becomes one part in 10,000, or 0.01%. If you paid 0.01% sales tax, you’d pay $1.00 on a new $10,000 car. Remember the Ivory Soap ad, with “99.44% pure?” Relative to dioxane content, you could still state that Tide F&G was “99.99% pure.”

To compare against the animal data – 1.0% in drinking water – we’re more than two orders of magnitude (100x) off . . .and, last time I checked, most people don’t drink laundry detergent.

Q4 – But these are chronic exposures, so doesn’t it build up over time?

If the entire detected amount were to be absorbed into your body each time, maybe so. However, given dioxane’s high water solubility, and the large amount of water used to wash clothes relative to the tiny volume of detergent added, it’s likely that only a vanishingly small amount ever ends up stuck to your T-shirts.

Q5 – Tell me more about the science.

He wants to know your L.O.D.
Source: P&G / Tide
I thought you’d never ask! To start, the samples were analyzed at Analytical Sciences, LLC, in Petaluma, CA, using selective ion mass spectrometry. Theoretically, this selectively targets the ion of interest and increases the sensitivity of the instrument for this analyte. However, note the Limits of Detection (p. 15) for dioxane = 250 ppm. So, how are they accurately measuring below their L.O.D.? Where are the error bars, or ranges for multiple runs? No analytical chemist ever uses a single data point to prove an argument. Add in pseudo-scientific statements such as “analytical analysis,” and “very specific mass spectral ions,” and you wonder who Q.C.’d this report! The nail in the coffin, however, has to be the asterisks (***) that litter the analysis section, including these statements in tiny font, buried under the data:
*These measurements represent levels detected in laboratory testing, and may not represent actual exposure levels experienced with use of the product in the home… 
***In most cases, research has never been conducted to determine if exposure to the chemical through use of the cleaning product is associated with the health outcome.
Wile E. Chemist
Source: Chuck Jones / Looney Tunes
Despite the obviously inflammatory titles of the petition and the report, and the overwhelmingly negative bias towards all those “dirty chemicals” made by wily chemists, I can empathize: the petition addresses moms, and its message aims to keep children safe. I’m sure the scientists at P&G, many of whom have their own kids, want to keep children safe, too! However, in my opinion, this report should not be the ideological or scientific basis for thousands of social-media-equipped petitioners to vent their frustration.

(Update: 3/8, 2:30AM - Minor grammatical changes)


  1. Sorry everyone! Somehow, the comment thread got all screwed up for this post...working on it!

  2. Thanks for this post. Wish more people understood science, statistics and risk. Maybe then people would not freak out and take a side so quickly.

  3. Some people are probably confusing 1,4-dioxane with TCDD (& related polychlorinated dibenzodioxins), a really nasty compound commonly and incorrectly called dioxin.

  4. Thanks for posting this! I have so many facebook friends that circulate these petitions against X, Y, or Z, and it is so frustrating! They don't understand the science behind these studies and why they generally aren't very scientific at all! They see the word "chemical" or "cancer" and run for the hills!

  5. This reminds me of the time a high school student distributed a report on the hazards of dihydrogen monoxide to classmates. 86% thought DHMO should be banned. (Dihydrogen Monoxide: Unrecognized Killer, Washington Post, Oct. 21, 1997 if you want to look it up.)

  6. Excellent for our annual haunted house! Thanks for sharing this idea. Here you can how do you make slime with laundry detergent at home.

  7. We are supplier of high Quality research chemicals at good and affordable prices.
    We ship worldwide with tracking provided.
    Special discounts provided for bulk orders and payments via Bitcoin.

    - Buy With Bitcoin or Other Crypto currencies.
    - Good quality Chemicals.
    - Good and affordable prices.
    - 100% Money Back Guaranteed!
    - Fast and Reliable delivery With Tracking Available!
    - Various shipping option (Overnight and Airmail).
    - Buy Direct and Save Time and Money!
    - 100% Customer Satisfaction Guaranteed!

    Contact Us Via Details Below:

    Text: +1 (443) 526-1509,
    Wickr Id: jasonstewart

    Products Available In Stock:

    *** SPECIAL SALES ***

    - Buy Liquid Mercury,
    - Buy Potassium Cyanide (KCN),
    - Buy GHB,
    - Buy Ketamine,
    - Buy Nembutal,
    - Buy Seconal,
    - Buy LSD,
    - Buy Ecstasy,


    - Buy 4-CN-BINACA-ADB,
    - Buy 5-CL-ADB-A,
    - Buy 5F-AB-PINACA,
    - Buy 5F-AKB-48,
    - Buy 5F-AMB,
    - Buy 5F-CUMYL-PINACA,
    - Buy 5F-MDMB-2201,
    - Buy 5F-MN-18,
    - Buy 5F-MN-24,
    - Buy 5F-SDB-005,
    - Buy 5F-SDB-006,
    - Buy 5F-SGT-151,
    - Buy AB-001,
    - Buy AB-CHMINACA,
    - Buy AKB-57,
    - Buy Anandamide,
    - BuY 38-7271,
    - Buy BB-22,
    - Buy EG-018,
    - Buy FAB-144,
    - Buy FUB-PB-22,
    - Buy MA-CHMINACA,
    - Buy NM-2201,
    - Buy PX-1,
    - Buy SGT-263,
    - Buy THJ-018,
    - Buy THJ-2201,
    - Buy UR-144,


    - Buy 2-A1MP,
    - Buy 2-methyl-MAF,
    - Buy 23b-PVP,
    - Buy 2C-E,
    - Buy 2C-P,
    - Buy 3-FPM,
    - Buy 3C-E,
    - Buy 4-BMC,
    - Buy 4-CEC,
    - Buy 4-Cl-PVP,
    - Buy 4-CMC,
    - Buy 4-CPrC,
    - Buy 4-EMC,
    - Buy 4-FA,
    - Buy 4-MEC,
    - Buy 4-MPD,
    - Buy 4F-MPH,
    - Buy 4F-PHP,
    - Buy 4F-PV9,
    - Buy 4F-PVP,
    - Buy 5-APB,
    - Buy 5-APDB,
    - Buy 5-EAPB,
    - Buy 5-MAPB,
    - Buy 5-Methylethylone,
    - Buy 6-APB,
    - Buy A-PHP,
    - Buy A-PiHP,
    - Buy A-PVP,
    - Buy A-PVT,
    - Buy Carfentanil,
    - Buy Dibutylone,
    - Buy Dimethylphenidate,
    - Buy Ethylone,
    - Buy Ethylphenidate,
    - Buy HDEP-28,
    - Buy MDMP,
    - Buy MDPPP,
    - Buy MDPV,
    - Buy Methiopropamine,
    - Buy Mexedrone,
    - Buy MOPPP,
    - Buy N-Ethyl-Hexedrone,
    - Buy PV-8,
    - Buy U-47700,
    - Buy U-48800,

    ==> OTHER:

    - Buy 2-OXO-PCE,
    - Buy 25I-NBOH,
    - Buy 25I-NBOMe,
    - Buy 3-MeO-PCP,
    - Buy 4-HO-MET,
    - Buy 4-HO-MiPT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-DaLT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-MiPT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-NiPT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-pyr-T,
    - Buy Allylescaline,
    - Buy Bk-2C-B,
    - Buy Diclazepam,
    - Buy Dimethylone,
    - Buy Diphenidine,
    - Buy DPT ,
    - Buy Etizolam,
    - Buy Flubromazepam,
    - Buy Methoxetamine,
    - Buy Methoxphenidine,
    - Buy ZDCM-04,

    Many other Chemicals available though not mention above.

    we do supply others products upon request if you need. We offer the most reliable transaction and sell at affordable prices. We ship worldwide and offer one of the best discreet delivery service to our customer's address.

    Please feel free to contact us for more details.

    Text: +1 (443) 526-1509,
    Wickr Id: jasonstewart


    We offer a variety of Financial packages at a very low interest rate, We stand apart from other lenders because we believe in customer service, We offer the right solution to your financial needs.In general we are FINANCE COMPANY, We offer loan at 2% interest rate, Commercial loans, business loans, home loans, car loans and debt consolidation loan are available for you. Contact us for more information via E-MAIL:

    Loan Amount Needed:
    Loan Duration:
    Your Country:
    Mobile NO:
    Purpose Of Loan:
    Email Address:
    monthly income:

    Thanks and best regards
    Mr Collins Guzman
    WhatsApp or Text: +1 (786) 598-8751

  9. Nembutal Liquid, Pentobarbital (trade name: Nembutal) is a drug from the barbiturate class. It was widely used during the 1940s and 1950s as a sleeping pill.Discover ideas about James Bond. Purchase nembutal online from VIDA TERMINO. We have high quality nembutal for sale.
    Click here for Buy Nembutal Onlinel

  10. Hi
    Thank you for sharing a knowledgeable blog with us I hope that you will post many more blog with us:

    Buy nembutal online and have it shipped to your home, We supply nembutal sodium solution, nembutal pills, and powder nembutal. We ship Spain, Italy, Germany, Portugal, Mexico. We got high quality pentobarbital for sale and we ship our products worldwide.

    Click here for Buy Nembutal Tablets USA

  11. Hi
    Thank you for sharing a knowledgeable blog with us I hope that you will post many more blog with us:

    Buy nembutal online and have it shipped to your home, We supply nembutal sodium solution, nembutal pills, and powder nembutal. We ship Spain, Italy, Germany, Portugal, Mexico. We got high quality pentobarbital for sale and we ship our products worldwide.

    Click here for Buy Pentobarbital Online

  12. Contact us Securely : keys2pharm {at }gmail (.)com |
    - Wickr: { keys2pharm}
    Purchasing medicines from a Reliable Source Without your Prescription online. We sell pharmacy grade medications only from trusted manufacturers, When you become a valued Customer of our online Pharmacy, you no longer have to worry about looking elsewhere, We sell discreetly and do stealth shipments to customers with no package sign-off upon delivery
    Our services

    We offer:
    * High #Quality Pharmacy Grade Medications.
    * Good and #Affordable prices.
    * Fast and Stealth delivery - #Tracking Available!
    * Various Discreet Shipping option (Overnight and Normal Plan ).
    * No Prescription Required ( No Rx )
    * Buy Direct Save Time and Money,
    * Offers Reshipment if the package does not get to location or refunds

    (Fast,Reliable & Discreet) - Cryptocurrency PAYMENTS ONLY

    Painkillers, stimulants, sleeping pills & Anxiety Pills

    - Ambien 10mg,
    - Hi tech Promethazine Codeine Purple,
    - Adderall XR & IR30mg,
    - Ativan 2mg,
    - Clonazepam 2mg,
    - Codeine 30mg and 60mg,
    - Dilaudid 8mg,
    - Dsuvia 30mcg,
    - Fentanyl Patches 75 and 100mcg,
    - Hydrocodone 10/325mg ,7.5/325 mg,
    - Lortab 5/500, 7.5/325 and 10/500mg,
    - Ketamine 100ml
    - Methadone 10mg,
    - Morphine 60mg and 100 mg,
    - quality MDMA capsules for sale
    - Norco 10/325mg,
    - Opana 20mg and 40mg,
    - Oxycotin 20mg ,40mg and 80 mg,
    - Percocet 5/325mg, 10/325mg ,7.5/325mg,
    - Ritalin 10mg,
    - Roxicodone 15mg and 30mg,
    - Vyvanse 50, 70mg,
    - Seconal 100mg sodium( pills,etc),
    - Alprazolam 2mg / Green Bars / Green hulk bars/ S 90 3 bars,

    We do have other meds though not mention in the above list.

    Bitcoins payments now Accepted -MEDICATIONS - Buy with bitcoins or Cryptocurrencies - Painkillers and Stimulants medications
    Interested person should inbox

    contact via
    Email - keys2pharm {@} Gmail {.}com /
    - W!ckr us at: keys2pharm


    Buy Oxycodone Online No prescription | buy Adderall 30mg Online | Order Subutex Online | buy Roxicodone 30mg | Buy Subutex 8mg Online | Buy suboxone online | Buy Oxycontin Online, Buy Amphetamine online, Codeine and Hydrocodone Buy Oxycontin 80mg online | buy Percocet online | Buy Dilaudid 8mg online | Buy Ketamine Online quality MDMA capsules for sale

  13. Buy Desoxyn for ADHD without needing a script
    You can purchase Desoxyn for ADHD at discounted prices
    Delivery and quality all guaranteed
    Other ADHD products are als available order now by calling or texting the numbers below