Saturday, February 18, 2012

Are You Scared Yet?**

Sensationalist journalism pervades our society. Usually, investigators focus their attention on stores, local government, unions, and the like. But chemistry labs...are they terrorist plots waiting to happen? Lucky for us, ChemBark to the rescue! His post Friday (click over there to see the video in all its scandal-filled and melodramatic musical glory) alerts the chemical community to a pressing National Security emergency: unlocked research labs in otherwise nondescript academic buildings.

To reiterate Paul's main point: yes, the labs in question should not have been so easy to access. Most of the academic labs I've worked in have had key card / ID fob access built into the doors, and critical facilities (storerooms, NMR, clean rooms) behind keypad-locked doors, or good old-fashioned metal lock and key.

Cogent arguments aside, the piece fails on just about every level for meaningful chemistry communication. Here's a random sampling of quotes from the story:

0:10 "...just the right chemicals to make a bomb?"
Well, most bombs require high explosives, like nitroglycerin or TNT. As most readers of this blog realize, materials such as iodine or hydrazine - unlike the dilute HCl or ethyl ether featured in the news spot - can actually be used to make bombs, and are under strict DOT and DHS purchase regulations.

0:53 - What's with the gunshots? Since when did that have anything to do with organic chemistry labs?

1:16 - "Compounds that could potentially be used in terrorist attacks"
While (potentially) true, you're more likely to find allyl alcohol in drug leads, and acrylonitrile in superglue!

A real-live chemical storeroom (not caught on tape, sadly)
Credit: University of Delaware / Fisher Scientific
1:20 - Oh no, duck and cover, that scientist is using a Karl Fischer apparatus!

1:35 - "...inside this glass case..."  Did you mean a fume hood, perchance? ...which improves lab safety?

2:43 - "...chemistry lab and storeroom." Have these people ever seen a chemical storeroom?

2:50 - "...cabinets, some unlocked, labeled ACIDS and FLAMMABLES."
Were the researchers supposed to just store them in plain gray cabinets? I would argue that the labels increase safety. Also, if they were allegedly "unlocked," why is there no camera shot of a cabinet door hanging open?

3:05 - "...large nitrogen tanks..." If the announcer knew that he was referring to liquid nitrogen, he'd be doubly afraid!

3:54 - "...hydrochloric acid, a highly corrosive chemical that can burn skin to the bone"
This bottle reminds me of the 1.0N HCl shown earlier (1:29).  If anyone's wondering, the pH of 1N HCl is 0.1, which, while enough to give you some decent skin irritation, won't char you on contact. I see no concentrated HCl anywhere, and even that's no TFA or triflic acid.

4:07 - "...ethyl ether, a highly flammable solvent that could cause respiratory problems!"
Or knock you out for surgery, like in the olden days at the MGH Ether Dome.

6:01 - "schools must list their chemicals of interest, but only if those chemicals exceed a certain amount"
This sounds an awful lot like "the dose makes the poison." (i.e., it's terribly tough to mount a terrorist attack with 25 g of magnesium sulfate...)

**Just for those keeping score at home, I counted 26 mentions of the word "chemical" (or once every 14.4 seconds). Always preceded by a sensationalist adjective like "dangerous," "deadly," "interest," "maim," or "flammable." 

12 comments:

  1. Worrying about chemistry labs makes little sense unless the availability of natural gas, oxygen tanks, propane, etc. is restricted first. Terrorists could make a much bigger bang with a fuel-air explosion or pressurized fuel-oxygen bomb. Actually, they don't even need a bomb - they could probably paralyze North America by leaving totally harmless but suspicious-looking packages in a half dozen key locations, particularly if they contain white powder or a piece of uranium ore. Security can't work - as the saying goes, the emperor has no clothes. Of course, terrorists are just as incompetent as security.
    (A challenge for readers - figure out how to defuse a pressurized fuel-oxygen bomb.)

    ReplyDelete
  2. @gippgig - Agreed. As commenters from both ChemBark and MetaFilter are quick to point out, so long as you can still buy fertilizer, car batteries, and strong acids and bases from hardware stores, these remain much bigger threats than under-secure labs.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Answer to the challenge: Freeze it (i.e., with liquid He). When the components condense the pressure will drop to near zero. It can then be opened (to a vacuum or He) and slowly warmed. The components should distill off separately. Done.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I overlooked that all you need to make a bomb is water and electricity. Try limiting the availability of that!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Gippgig, I still would want to be nowhere near. Seen liquid oxygen do its thing a few too many times :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. 'Tis true - I personally knew two (2) individuals in school who had LN2 traps for their high vacs slightly open during a crucial distillation or drying. Anyone want to guess the outcome of that? (hint, liquid oxygen REALLY wants to be gaseous again!)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'd have thought the pH of 1 M HCl (assuming blah blah) should be zero (10^0 = 1)... 1 M shouldn't be so concentrated that we have to worry about activity coefficients, or that the assumption that it dissociates completely should not hold?

    I was thinking of removing it to some place with wide open spaces... and vent to the atmosphere (preferably separately).

    ReplyDelete
  8. @Andrew - Not that MSDSs are ever wrong, but click that link above, and you'll get your answer in the "physical properties" section. Or, pour a little out in a cup, and dip some litmus paper in, and you'll notice the bright pink color of pH 0-1.

    The point I was trying for is as follows: no one's going to make an explosive device or terror weapon out of this acid. There's traces of iron and copper in our blood, but no one's casting ingots out of people, y'know?

    Best just to close the hood sash, keep an eyewash handy, and lock your lab doors.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I saw the MSDS, thanks. And I don't disagree with your point. Just going off on a tangent.

    ReplyDelete
  10. We are supplier of high Quality research chemicals at good and affordable prices.
    We ship worldwide with tracking provided.
    Special discounts provided for bulk orders and payments via Bitcoin.


    - Buy With Bitcoin or Other Crypto currencies.
    - Good quality Chemicals.
    - Good and affordable prices.
    - 100% Money Back Guaranteed!
    - Fast and Reliable delivery With Tracking Available!
    - Various shipping option (Overnight and Airmail).
    - Buy Direct and Save Time and Money!
    - 100% Customer Satisfaction Guaranteed!


    Contact Us Via Details Below:

    Email: info.31chemicals@gmail.com
    Text: +1 (443) 526-1509,
    Wickr Id: jasonstewart


    Products Available In Stock:

    *** SPECIAL SALES ***

    - Buy Liquid Mercury,
    - Buy Potassium Cyanide (KCN),
    - Buy GHB,
    - Buy Ketamine,
    - Buy Nembutal,
    - Buy Seconal,
    - Buy LSD,
    - Buy Ecstasy,


    ==>> CANNABINOIDS:

    - Buy 4-CN-BINACA-ADB,
    - Buy 5-CL-ADB-A,
    - Buy 5F-AB-PINACA,
    - Buy 5F-AKB-48,
    - Buy 5F-AMB,
    - Buy 5F-CUMYL-PINACA,
    - Buy 5F-MDMB-2201,
    - Buy 5F-MN-18,
    - Buy 5F-MN-24,
    - Buy 5F-SDB-005,
    - Buy 5F-SDB-006,
    - Buy 5F-SGT-151,
    - Buy AB-001,
    - Buy AB-CHMINACA,
    - Buy AKB-57,
    - Buy AMB-FUBINACA,
    - Buy Anandamide,
    - BuY 38-7271,
    - Buy BB-22,
    - Buy CUMYL-4CN-BINACA,
    - Buy CUMYL-PINACA,
    - Buy EG-018,
    - Buy FAB-144,
    - Buy FUB-PB-22,
    - Buy MA-CHMINACA,
    - Buy MDMB-CHMINACA,
    - Buy NM-2201,
    - Buy PX-1,
    - Buy SGT-263,
    - Buy THJ-018,
    - Buy THJ-2201,
    - Buy UR-144,


    =>> Buy STIMULANTS ONLINE:

    - Buy 2-A1MP,
    - Buy 2-methyl-MAF,
    - Buy 23b-PVP,
    - Buy 2C-E,
    - Buy 2C-P,
    - Buy 3-FPM,
    - Buy 3C-E,
    - Buy 4-BMC,
    - Buy 4-CEC,
    - Buy 4-Cl-PVP,
    - Buy 4-CMC,
    - Buy 4-CPrC,
    - Buy 4-EMC,
    - Buy 4-FA,
    - Buy 4-MEC,
    - Buy 4-MPD,
    - Buy 4F-MPH,
    - Buy 4F-PHP,
    - Buy 4F-PV9,
    - Buy 4F-PVP,
    - Buy 5-APB,
    - Buy 5-APDB,
    - Buy 5-EAPB,
    - Buy 5-MAPB,
    - Buy 5-Methylethylone,
    - Buy 6-APB,
    - Buy A-PHP,
    - Buy A-PiHP,
    - Buy A-PVP,
    - Buy A-PVT,
    - Buy Carfentanil,
    - Buy Dibutylone,
    - Buy Dimethylphenidate,
    - Buy Ethylone,
    - Buy Ethylphenidate,
    - Buy HDEP-28,
    - Buy MDMP,
    - Buy MDPPP,
    - Buy MDPV,
    - Buy Methiopropamine,
    - Buy Mexedrone,
    - Buy MOPPP,
    - Buy N-Ethyl-Hexedrone,
    - Buy PV-8,
    - Buy U-47700,
    - Buy U-48800,


    ==> OTHER:

    - Buy 2-OXO-PCE,
    - Buy 25I-NBOH,
    - Buy 25I-NBOMe,
    - Buy 3-MeO-PCP,
    - Buy 4-HO-MET,
    - Buy 4-HO-MiPT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-DaLT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-MiPT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-NiPT,
    - Buy 5-MeO-pyr-T,
    - Buy Allylescaline,
    - Buy Bk-2C-B,
    - Buy Diclazepam,
    - Buy Dimethylone,
    - Buy Diphenidine,
    - Buy DPT ,
    - Buy Etizolam,
    - Buy Flubromazepam,
    - Buy Methoxetamine,
    - Buy Methoxphenidine,
    - Buy ZDCM-04,



    Many other Chemicals available though not mention above.

    we do supply others products upon request if you need. We offer the most reliable transaction and sell at affordable prices. We ship worldwide and offer one of the best discreet delivery service to our customer's address.

    Please feel free to contact us for more details.

    31 CHEMICALS
    Email: info.31chemicals@gmail.com
    Text: +1 (443) 526-1509,
    Wickr Id: jasonstewart

    ReplyDelete
  11. How to Order Prescription Drugs Safely Online | Where to Order Prescription Drugs Safely Online.Research Chemicals,VENOMOUS
    Where to Buy Research Chemicals Online | Buy Barbiturates Online | Buy Human Growth Hormone (HGH) Online

    We supply good quality Benzodiazepines, Pain Medications, Anxiety Medications, Relief Medications, Insomnia Medications, Weight Lost

    Medications, Stimulants, Opiate/Opioid, Research Chemicals, etc...
    We ship with the United States and we do ship worldwide as well with tracking number provided.
    We now offer 30% Discount, Contact us or Check out Our stocks and Prices using the details below:

    Contact Us:
    Delta Bioresearch Chemicals
    Text & Call:+86 (184) 7507-2355
    Text:+1(619) 356-8501
    Whatsapp:+1(619) 356-8501
    Email:support@deltabioresearchchemicals.com

    buy xanax powder online
    buy bk-mdma online
    buy etizolam powder online
    Buy Alpha-PVP Drug Online
    buy th-pvp crystal,

    - Buy Oxycontin Online
    - Buy Roxycodone Online
    - Buy Rohypnol Online
    - Buy Hydrocodone Online
    - Buy Vicodin Online
    - Buy Ketamine Online
    - Buy Soma Online
    - Buy Viagra Online
    - Buy Dexedrine Online
    - Buy Mandrax Online (Quaalude)
    - Buy Fentanyl Online
    - Buy Demerol Online
    - Buy Lyrica Online , etc.
    For more visit: deltabioresearchchemicals.com/


    ** Research Chemicals **
    - Buy Etizolam Online
    - Buy Ketamine Online
    - Buy 25I-NBOMe Online
    - Buy 3-MMC Online
    - Buy Mephedrone Online
    - Buy Ephedrine Hcl Online
    - Buy Esctacy Online (MDMA)
    - Buy A-pvp Online
    - Buy Crystal Meth Online
    - Buy Ethylone Online , etc....


    Other good stuffs like:
    - Buy Potassium Cyanide (KCN) Online
    - Buy Ketamine Online
    - Buy MDMA (Ecstasy) Online
    - Buy Carfentanil Online

    Are also available. Just have a look at our website for more products, feel free to have a look:

    venom:
    snake Venoms
    Spiders Venoms
    Scorpions Venoms
    more

    Contact Us:
    Delta Bioresearch Chemicals
    Text & Call:+86 (184) 7507-2355
    Text:+1(619) 356-8501
    Whatsapp:+1(619) 356-8501
    Email:support@deltabioresearchchemicals.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. buy alprazolam,ketamine,mdma,crystal meth,fentanyl at https://shop4herbalincense.com

    Order Fentanyl, Oxycodone, Buy Mephedrone online, Xanax Bars , Percs , Roxicodone at low cost..With us , you get meds discreet with no prescription. We've worked to create a fast,
    efficient and fair system for order processing. We know you want your order quickly, at the lowest possible cost.Check some of our highly purchased meds;

    We are the best supplier of pain medications and research chemicals .our prices are affordable .
    For more details contact our website through any of the details provided below
    Management

    Visit: https://shop4herbalincense.com


    Call: +1 (925)-338-9583 (USA/Canada)

    whatsapp: +1 (925)-338-9583

    ReplyDelete