Sunday, October 23, 2011

The Chemistry Popularity Conundrum

Last week (October 16-22) was National Chemistry Week in the US. Did you celebrate? By all rights, it could have been the biggest one yet, since we’re deep into the tenth month of the International Year of Chemistry (#IYC2011). Did you see any news specials? Did Time or Newsweek run an exposé?

Credit: time.com
Probably not, but why not? When scientists cracked the human genetic code, front pages everywhere relayed the tense horse-race between Venter’s TIGR and Collins’s Human Genome Project. Whenever physicists flip the switch at the Large Hadron Collider, the public dreams of mini-black holes and cheating Einstein’s relativity. Chemistry, however, always seems to be the black sheep of the gang; DuPont’s slogan for nearly 50 years was “Better Things for Better Living . . .Through Chemistry,” until the final portion of the tagline was dropped in the mid-‘80s.
What creates the chemistry image problem? It’s true that many of the “pure chemistry” accomplishments of the last 30 years have gone largely unnoticed: ask someone at a local restaurant about triblock copolymers, organocatalysis, brevetoxin, or dye-sensitized solar cells. Applied chemistry fares a bit better, from polymers to paints, lasers to ligands, but the public still attributes many interface discoveries to other fields – drug chemistry gets lumped into “Health and Medicine,” or water-splitting tossed in with “New Energy.”
Don't let the test-tube on the front fool you.
Credit: amazon.com
The phenomenon even reaches general science books. On a whim, I opened up National Geographic’s The Science Book (bonus tagline – Everything You Need to Know about the World and How it Works) at a book store last week. A hefty volume, coming in at 432 pp., thus you might expect the “central science” to occupy at least 30% . . . right?
Wrong. Page count: biology, ecology, and sociology – 142 pages.  Physics, math, and ‘technology’ – 111 pages. Chemistry? 26 pages.
Total.
Does this all come down to poor public relations? Biology sells itself on some big questions: origin of life, evolution, ending disease, and genetic engineering. Physics moves out onto an even wider plane: does God exist?, fundamental particles, dark energy, string theory, and black holes. Ask most people about the word chemical, however, and their connotation is tangibly negative, associating the word with poisonous, pollution, ersatz stand-ins for “genuine” flavors or fragrances, artificial, corrosive, or toxic.
Prof. David MacMillan, Princeton
Not that none have addressed the issue – just recently, David MacMillan, editor of Chemical Science and accomplished organic chemist, called for increased outreach:    
‘One major thing chemists need to work on is their ability to promote their work to other scientists and the public. This is something we are really not good at in general and if we improved, it would really open doors for us and improve society’s perception of chemistry and its impact.'

ACS attempts much the same with their Chemistry Ambassadors program, and the Interactive Periodic Table of Videos surely adds some demonstration “Wow!” factor. But the days of science-themed programs (Mr. Wizard, NOVA, How it’s Made, even the tongue-in-cheek Look Around You) seem to have waned, and Mythbusters can’t save the whole genre single-handedly. Linus Pauling, Noam Chomsky, Carl Sagan, Stephen Hawking, Steven Pinker, E.O. Wilson, and Oliver Sacks have held down much of the science PR fort, but we still haven’t found the next great chemistry “populizer.” So, what are we to do?

Can these guys hold down the science program genre forever?
Credit: dsc.discovery.com
Well, I’m not the first to tackle this question. Luckily, many have gone before me: see Dr. Free Ride’s post on Scientopia (“navel-gazing” sounds so apropos) or the CHEMisperceptions Blog Roundtable from early 2011 hosted at ScienceGeist. Start there, and glance through the situations and stories these authors present. See where you stand.

And think. Just think.
Think about how you’ll answer the dreaded “So, what do you do?” question at the next holiday party. Think about a show you wish were on TV, DVD, or radio that covered breaking-edge reactions or materials, but isn’t. Think about how you might tell such a story. Think about what types of jobs you, as a chemist, might envision working in 10, 20 years . . . if they even exist right now! Think of the reactions, equations, elements, polymers, or drugs (heh) that really ‘get you up’ in the morning.
When you’ve thought awhile, narrow down your list to one or two things you truly enjoy. Write a short blog post or a newspaper article. Send an email. Take some pictures. Tell your kids. Teach a short course. Write a book. Produce a show. Anything you can do that creates new, high-quality content to help improve the stead of science in the world will do.
Idealistic?  Sure.   
Dreamy?  You got me.
Possible?
. . . I’d like to think so.
(Note: You don’t have to start from nothing - there’s quite a few folks already working on the problem. For general chemistry blogs, start at CENtral Science. Work your way around to Chemistry Blog, Discover Magazine, SciAm Blogs, and Popular Science. Chemjobber, The Curious Wavefunction, and ChemBark help capture some of the current chemical zeitgeist, while Totally Synthetic and BRSM cover my favorite topic, chemical synthesis. For health and medicine, try In The Pipeline or The Medicine Show. Want books? Napoleon’s Buttons, The Poisoner’s Handbook, Mauve, and Uncle Tungsten are a few favorites. On a personal note, although he’s not formally a chemist, Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman! and What Do You Care What Other People Think? helped me appreciate how one can use scientific curiosity to change the world.)

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

I'm Not Dead Yet

Good guess, but not where we're going...
Hello, readers . . .you may have noticed a lot of down time around here lately. Truth be told, we're planning a wee bit of "geographical displacement" brought on by "employment improvement" (Translation: a multi-state move is in the works).

More posts after the jump, I promise!

Friday, September 23, 2011

In Which You are What You Eat

I love food. Always have – both the process of making food (which may be why I’m a synthetic chemist) and the joy of consuming one’s labors (which lab work definitely doesn’t allow!). Recently, however, modern science blurs the line between the stomach and brain. “You are what you eat” no longer just refers to body weight or proper nutrient intake. We humans are superorganisms, meaning that our intestinal microbiology plays a huge role in our everyday lives. Turns out, where you were born, where you live, what you eat, and where you’ve travelled can all influence the metabolic phenotype (appearance) of the bacteria that inhabit your intestinal tract.
Hey baby, what's your gut microbiome?
Credit: Healthy Perceptions blog
Some microbiologists posit that humans can be grouped, not by race, creed, height, or sex, but by “gut profile.”  A recent multi-institution Nature paper, led by Bork and Ehrlich, disclosed three major enterotypes (gut profiles), based on DNA sequencing (of, well, poop) of 22 people from 4 different countries. The scientists try not to paint too broad a picture with this initial result, but note that gut bacteria influence key genes that regulate aging and body mass index, which may suggest microbial management of a wide variety of diseases.
Your gut bacteria also impact your emotions. WSJ’s Jonah Lehrer reports that yogurt – specifically the kind filled with “good” (probiotic) bacteria – can actually cause marked behavioral effects, at least in mice. Probiotic-fed mice showed fewer symptoms of stress and anxiety, even when placed in new situations. An ideal cure for modern social anxiety, right? Unfortunately, no: other scientists interviewed quickly point out neurological patients’ inability to feel fear or stress causes them to make even worse future decisions in similar situations, since they lack the negative feedback from the prior event.
Mmm, gene regulation!
Credit: eating-in.com
Yogurt aside, your salad may also be helping to regulate your genes. Earlier this week, researchers in China disclosed new methods that can detect short strands of plant-derived RNA present in human bodily fluids. The researchers were especially surprised to find certain microRNAs actually inhibited the removal of LDL (low-density lipoprotein, the so-called “bad cholesterol”) from the bloodstream. Overall, the team found about 40 different microRNAs, from at least five different crops, and expects to find many more. Just more news to chew on, while you ruminate over your afternoon snack.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

Musings: Who are Chemists, Anyway?

When I’m performing a repetitive lab task (columns, iterative dilutions, etc.), my mind tends to drift. Yesterday, I began thinking about who I actually work with, where they come from, and why they’re in chemistry. Ever heard Jeff Foxworthy perform “You Might be a Redneck if…”? What if someone were to compile a similar list about synthetic chemists?
Thus, a few observations, from the subset of, say, 300 chemists I’ve worked with over the last ten years:
"It's OK, Dom, I'm leaving baseball for grad school"
Credit: AP
They tend to be older siblings: Perhaps there exists out there somewhere a biotech run entirely by younger sibs, but I haven’t found it yet! At my current job, all senior managers are the oldest siblings in their families, and I’m fairly certain most of the bench chemists have younger brothers and sisters. Maybe the old nature / nurture debate surfaces here, where parents encourage older children to pursue medical and scientific careers.
Folks come from all over: I hail from a town that the 2000 Census dubbed >95% Caucasian. Many of my friends went off to school, and then moved immediately back to town. After college, I moved 700 miles away, possibly to escape this exact fate! This "lifestyle inertia" has never occurred at any of the six labs I’ve worked in: the scientific population integrates well (math joke here?). My coworkers have hailed from all over the US, plus every continent except Greenland. It’s fun to watch Russian postdocs tell jokes to Indian coworkers, while French, Chinese, and Iranian labmates listen in and laugh.
Tech-savvy:  The first Blackberry I ever saw was wielded by a chemist. Ditto iPads, USB sticks, and noise-cancelling headphones. In grad school or college, you’ve probably used MacOS, UNIX / Linux, and most of the Microsoft Office suite, and you may have created .pdfs, manipulated graphics files, or solved crystal structures. It comes with the territory.

Merit badges = Future PhD?
Credit: watc.edu

Be Prepared? Four of my former coworkers were Eagle Scouts, and several more have EMT and First Responder training. Safety first.
Hobbies? Try second careers: Bench chemists live two lives: they’re passionate about their chemistry, but everyone has a hobby that they could fall back on (maybe a necessary practice in a bum economy). I’ve met semi-professional musicians, day traders, lay pastors, auto mechanics, authors, aerobics instructors, economists, coaches, show promoters, bodybuilders, shop owners, and even professional dancers.
Credit: rushpassport.com
World Travelers: Maybe this makes sense given their international background, but chemists travel all over. Many save up their whole vacation allotment for 2-3 years, and then go to China, France, Australia, or Argentina. Back when large chemical concerns had travel budgets (I know, a novel conceit), chemists could rely on at least one expedition per year, usually to attend a big conference in a far-flung locale.
Not Fashion Plates: You won’t see many chemists dressing like the men and women striding down docks in J.Crew, or taking nighttime strolls like they do in Ralph Lauren catalogs. Perhaps it’s thrift, or comfort, or maybe chemists just realize that their clothes have limited lifetimes in synthetic labs.
Office Pool?  Of course!  Chemists tend to jump at opportunities to participate in NCAA tourneys, fantasy football, or poker nights. Maybe it’s the competition? The odds? The logic? Who knows! I’ve worked in labs where two competing tournaments have been run simultaneously…and both found plenty of participants.
Wanna join our league?
Credit: tradebit.com
One-Upsmanship: Many of the conversations I’ve had with older chemists invariably come down to competitions over how hard the job once was. Usually, they begin with “Oh yeah? Well, when I was your age, we had to recrystallize everything to purity, we didn’t have working fume hoods, and we actually used the (insert here name of old, dusty apparatus in the corner no one ever uses).” Maybe this speaks to how much synthetic chemists enjoy competition (see above).
War Stories and Battle Scars: No, I’m not talking about actual military service, although I’ve worked with a few chemists who have bravely fought alongside our troops. I refer to tales career chemists always tell at bars, stories where pump traps explode, flames shoot up from flasks, and injury was narrowly avoided. If you work in a synthetic lab long enough, you’ll have a few close calls, and you might even have something to show for it: a bald spot here, a burn there, even some stitches now and again.

Thursday, September 8, 2011

Come On, Allene! The Crabbé Reaction

Readers: This post was written in response to Rachel Pepling’s call for submissions to the IYC2011 Chemistry Carnival over at CENtral Science
Have you ever been in love?
Has a single, chance moment changed your outlook on life?
Did you ever have the burning desire to . . . add one little methylene group to the end of an alkyne?
I’m an organic chemist, and our emotions tend to track directly with the success of our bench work. In my third year of graduate school, I felt down in the dumps.  My methodology project had no traction; heck, I couldn’t even make the (relatively simple) allene substrates I needed in less than five steps! Such was life when, during my group meeting presentation, a voice chimed in from one of the postdocs sitting in the far corner of the room:
“I think there’s a reaction for this.  Haven’t you tried the Crabbé?”
Credit: scenicreflections.com
(At first, I stared agog, since the name made it sound like he was ordering seafood in a fancy French restaurant, so I thought he was joking, but he wasn’t!)
Turned out, there was a “chemical shortcut” to do just what I needed: the Crabbé takes a terminal alkyne under Mannich-like conditions (di-isopropylamine, formaldehyde, dioxane) – with a dash of copper (I) bromide for good measure – and adds a methylene (=CH2) unit to form an allene (see scheme). Why make allenes, you ask?  The two alkenes in this three-carbon synthon are orthogonal (at a 90o angle), which twists their pi-electron clouds away from one another. Thus, each olefin can react independently in reactions like metal coordination or electrophile addition.
The reaction mechanism made me scratch my head for a while, just as it did Crabbé’s researchers working at U. Missouri in the early 1980s. These chemists propose that, after the initial Mannich adduct forms, a copper atom wiggles into coordination between the amine and the alkyne. When you crank up the heat, the amine kicks out a hydride (H-) from an isopropyl group, which then migrates to the copper. This copper hydride spins around, delivers its hydride payload to the alkyne, and kicks out an imine leaving group. 

Credit: Carl Sagan's Dance Party Blog

It’s a fairly chemoselective reaction, meaning you can use it late in the game in a synthesis (assuming your compound can survive heating in dioxane for a few hours with copper!). My favorite part? I enjoy watching the autumnal palette that evolves during the reaction, from birch-tree yellow to maple-leaf red. Different starting materials lend different shades. And, as most organic chemists will tell you, one-pot preps you can set up and forget about are the reactions we love.

Links and Such

A few recent internet chemistry items for your viewing enjoyment:

Paul is already hard at work predicting October's Nobel Prize in Chemistry.

Chemjobber waxes on vacation requirements (or not) in academic labs.


Hey look, nitrogen particles!  Wait, no, that's snow...
Over at Forbes, Matt has a profile of Peter Hirth, the man behind Sutent and Zelboraf.

Ivan Amato chats up horseradish and pain receptors in the Washington Post.

NPR's Morning Edition covered a recent Nature article, but what the heck is a "nitrogen particle"?

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Synthonix Rings Up an Advertising Coup

Gotta hand it to 'em: Synthonix sure can print a convincing ad!

One of these things is not like the others! Credit: Synthonix, Inc.
The Wake Forest, NC company has taken out a few full-page ads in C&EN: clean, simple black structures on white backgrounds, illustrating the wide variety of oxetane, azetidine, and spiro-heterocycles intended for stitching into med-chem lead molecules. But their latest ad, a portion of which is shown here, takes the cake.

As any Linnaean taxonomist can tell you (*Kings Play Chess On Fat Grey Stools, anyone?), classification runs deep in the scientific blood. When you consider the sheer number of organic molecules that can exist (10^60 potential molecules of 500 MW or less?!), please forgive the namers for getting a little punchy. Molecules garner nicknames based on their appearance (propellanes, cubanes), their smell (putrescine, cadaverine), or other chemists (bullvalene)!

The naming convention for small, 5-membered heterocycles proceeds thusly: start with Latin or English names of the heteroatom, and add "ole" to the end (rhymes with "pole" or "coal," not like Olé!).

Phosphorus? = phosphole. Sulfur? = thiazole. And arsenic...?

(I'll let you figure that one out)

 (*Kingdom, Phylum, Class, Order, Family, Genus, Species...Bio 101 FTW!)